Aghnoo Nagesia vs State Of Bihar |

Aghnoo Nagesia vs State Of Bihar

Aghnoo Nagesia vs State Of Bihar

Brief facts of the case- The appellant was tried for murder. The principal evidence against him consisted of a first information report containing a full confession of the crime. The appellant was convicted under s. 302 Indian Penal Code by the trial court and the High Court upheld the conviction, By special leave he appealed to the Supreme Court.
The first information of the offences was lodged by the appellant himself at police station Palkot on August 11, 1963 at 3-15 p.m in the form of confessional F.I.R. The appellant was charged for murdering his aunt, Ratni, her daughter Chamin, her son-in-law, Somra and Dilu, son of somra. He was convicted and sentenced to death by the Judicial Commis- sioner of Chotanagpur. The High Court of Patna accepted the death reference, confirmed the conviction and sentence and dismissed the appeal preferred by the appellant.

Legal Issue- whether the whole confessional statement in the F.I.R. was banned by sec. 25 of the Indian Evidence Act or only those portions of it were barred which related to the actual commission of the crime.

Held-
1.The Supreme Court held that if the first information report is given by the accused to a police officer and amounts to a confessional statement, proof of the confession is prohibited by s. 25. The confession includes not only the admission of the offence but all other admissions of incriminating facts related to the offence contained in the confessional statement. No part of the confessional statement is receivable in evidence except to the extent that the ban of s. 25 is lifted by s.27.
2. The Court held that the separability test is misleading, and the entire confessional statement is hit by s.25 and save and except as provided by s. 27 and save and except the formal part identifying the accused as the maker of the report, no part of it could be tendered in evidence.
3. For the purposes of the case, the Supreme Court shall assume that the appellant was constructively in police custody and therefore the information contained in the first information report leading to the discovery of the dead bodies and the tangi is admissible in evidence. The entire evidence against the appellant then consists of the fact that the appellant gave information as to the place where the dead bodies were lying and as to the place where he concealed the tangi, the discovery of the dead bodies and the tangi in consequence of the information, the discovery of a blood-stained chadar from the appellant’s house and the fact that he had gone to Dungi Jharan Hills on the morning of August 11, 1963. This evidence is not sufficient to convict the appellant of the offenses under s. 302 of the Indian Penal Code.
In the result, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal, the conviction and sentence passed by the Courts below are set aside.

April 5, 2017

8 responses on "Aghnoo Nagesia vs State Of Bihar"

  1. thesis proposal writing service [url=http://thesissgj.com/]phd online[/url] thesis editing service thesis statistics help thesis abstracts online

  2. short term loans until payday [url=http://shorttermloanshek.com/]short term payday loans same day[/url] short term payday loans uk short term cash loans australia hard money loan after short sale

  3. fast payday loan tallahassee florida [url=http://fastcashloansvfl.com/]fast cash 5000 loan[/url] fast payday loans with no credit check fast and easy cash loan in cebu 2000 dollar fast cash loans

  4. viagra online [url=https://sophiapharmsd.com/]viagra dosage[/url] viagra for men buy viagra how to get viagra

  5. viagra coupons [url=https://abigailpharmdx.com/]viagra patent[/url] viagra overdose viagra 100mg how to get viagra

  6. viagra brand name [url=https://buyviagaraonline.com/]buy cheap viagra[/url] buy viagra on line viagra price comparison online viagra

  7. purchase viagra [url=https://avapharmyj.com/]natural alternatives to viagra[/url] order viagra online does viagra work viagra alternative

  8. london drugs canada [url=https://canadadrugpharmacywhik.com/]bringing prescription drugs into canada[/url] canada drugs direct reviews perscription drugs from canada drugs from canada to usa

Leave a Message

Your email address will not be published.

Copyright © 2017. Pahuja Law Academy
Designed & Developed By : Excel Range Media Group
Registration Opens For Judiciary Coaching


Register For Free Demo

Registration Opens For Judiciary Coaching
×
X
Free Demo Class Every Sunday - 10 AM & Every Wednesday - 04 PM                                    Free Demo Class Every Sunday - 10 AM & Every Wednesday - 04 PM